
Socialism kills -
See Also Europe's death toll rises by Joseph Farah
Posted: September 2, 2003
1:00 a.m. Eastern
© 2003 Creators Syndicate, Inc.
In a period of two weeks during August, more than 11,000 elderly
French men and women died of heat stroke. It is important to note this
is not nearly the scandal in France that it would be in America. In
fact, upon hearing the news, French president Jacques Chirac decided to
stay on vacation in Quebec, Canada.
Why not? Because, in the words of British historian Paul Johnson, the
French – like most Europeans, and like most left-thinking people
anywhere – love ideas more than people. The average educated European
can intelligently discuss Hegel or Matisse almost as well as the average
educated American – who probably never heard of Hegel or Matisse – can
discuss real estate or sports.
Europe has given the world Marxism, communism, fascism, Nazism,
racism and socialism, all rotten ideas that have caused immeasurable
human suffering. But for Europeans and their ideological twins on the
American left and at universities, ideas are not judged by their ability
to ameliorate human suffering or reduce evil, but by their complexity
and apparent profundity. An idea is not good because it produces good –
that's unromantic American pragmatism – it is good because it sounds
good.
Eleven thousand unnecessary deaths occurred in France largely because
socialism inevitably breeds hedonism, selfishness and callousness.
As ironic as it may seem, but the fact is that socialism – i.e.,
cradle-to-grave state welfare – makes people worse.
First, the socialist mind loathes work. In France, the legal length
of the work week is 35 hours. Working hard to make more money is an
American value that is held in contempt by the Left. The New York Times
recently featured an article describing the death of the Protestant work
ethic in secular, socialist Europe and the thriving of that ethic in
America – and that this explains the far greater productivity and
affluence of America. The Judeo-Christian tradition values work;
secularism doesn't. And as we all know from watching our children,
people with a lot of time on their hands have character problems.
Second, socialism values equality more than liberty. The Norwegian
government recently passed a law that the boards of its largest
corporations must be half female. The California left – the Democratic
Party – just passed a law that no employer may fire a male employee who
wears women's clothing at work. Because the Left holds liberty (except
sexual liberty) in lower esteem, Europe has raised a generation that
does not value liberty nearly as much as Americans do (though we're
getting there).
Third, socialism teaches you to avoid taking care of other people.
The state will – why should you? If people in France and elsewhere in
Europe take less care of their aging parents, it is because they are
taught from childhood to allow others – i.e., the state – to take care
of everybody. Just as we saw in America when the state stepped in to
take care of women who had children without a husband, these women
increasingly refused to marry and felt little compunction about having
more babies out of wedlock. The bigger the government, the worse the
people.
Fourth, as a result of this socialist mindset, people in socialist
countries give little charity, while Americans give vast amounts (just
as Americans in conservative states give more charity per capita than
people in liberal ones).
Fifth, the larger the state, the more callous it becomes.
Twentieth-century evil was made possible in large measure by the
bureaucratic mentality – the type of person who is merely a cog in huge
governmental machine, collectively all-powerful but individually
powerless to do anything except take and execute orders. The bigger the
state, the colder its heart. (It is also true that the bigger the
corporation, the more callous its heart. But unlike the state,
corporations have competition and have no police powers.)
As I wrote in a previous column, the future of the world is either
European secular socialism, Islamic totalitarianism or the unique
American combination of Judeo-Christian religiosity and political and
economic liberty.
Few Americans are attracted to the second possibility, but vast
numbers look to Europe as a model. One hopes that the next time they do,
they will note the 11,000 elderly dead in France. But don't bet on it.
Dennis Prager,
one of America's most respected and popular nationally syndicated radio
talk-show hosts, is the author of several books and a frequent guest on
television shows such as Larry King Live, Politically Incorrect, The
Late Late Show on CBS, Rivera Live, The Early Show on CBS, Fox Family
Network, The O'Reilly Factor and Hannity & Colmes. |